Home arrow Reports & Studies
PDF Print E-mail

Image

REPORTS & STUDIES

 

Three major aerial spraying programmes against moth pests have been carried out over heavily populated urban areas in New Zealand using the Bacillus thuringiensis var Kurstaki ( Btk) pesticide in the commercial formula Foray 48B. 

 

 

 

 

The aerial spraying took place in

  • East  Auckland  between 1996 and 1997 to control the White Spotted Tussock Moth;  
  • Hamilton City in late 2003 against a presumed infestation of the Asian Gypsy Moth, and
  • West Auckland ( Waitakere City) between 2002 and 2004 against the Painted Apple Moth.

 

A huge volume of reports, studies, surveys and investigations have arisen from these three eradication campaigns. The wealth of information, conclusions and recommendations contained in these comprehensive reports and studies is vital evidence that should be taken into account when assessing any  proposed aerial spray programmes in which there is inevitable and unavoidable public exposure.

 

All the reports and studies posted below have been commissioned  in New Zealand and relate to the New Zealand experience. Additionally, in conjunction with, and arising from these programmes, there has been a number of Government commissioned assessments and surveillance studies. Where available, these will be listed on the link below, together with relevant studies from overseas.

 

Link to NZ Government assessments and surveillance studies - and relevant overseas reports. 

 

Click on the titles to take you to pdf files of the reports. Click here for  Acrobat Reader if you haven't already got it.

 
PDF Print E-mail

October  2004:  Painted Apple Moth Eradication Campaign (legality of aerial spraying) – Report to the Prime Minister.

(pdf file)

Hana Blackmore for the PAM Community Network. October 2004.

 

 Report detailing serious concerns regarding the legality of continued aerial spraying, lack of public consultation and governmental review, and the failure of the compensation system.  Calls for urgent action and the setting up a full public inquiry. 

 
PDF Print E-mail

May 2003:   Is PAM Easy?

(pdf file)

John Clearwater,Phd. 

 

 Published in "The Spider's Web" newsletter (16) June 2003 8-9.

Analysis and comparison of two moth eradication projects, detailing critical decisions that resulted in two totally different outcomes. 

 
PDF Print E-mail

 

March 2003:   West Auckland aerial spraying survey

New Zealand Education Institute (NZEI)         

 

(pdf file) 

Correlated by Meredydd Barrar – NZEI West Auckland Committee of Management. March 2003. 

 

Survey of staff and principals in all West Auckland schools carried out during February 2003 on the effects of the Painted Apple Moth aerial spraying on teachers and pupils. 

 
PDF Print E-mail

Interim Report of the Community-based Health & Incident Monitoring of the Aerial Spray Programme. January – December 2002. 

( pdf file)

Hana Blackmore. February 2003. 

 

Report detailing the impacts and effects of the first year of the Painted Apple Moth aerial spraying programme.  Includes data recorded by the community from over 390 reported incidents.  Details for the first time the social and economic impacts, and questions the adequacy of the health risk assessment to accurately predict the level, extent and seriousness of the adverse effects.